Normal birth in Kazakhstan: Labor management practice in accordance with World Health Organization's recommendations
Aizhan D Kyzayeva1, Aigul B Kudamanova2
1 Department of Health Policy, Kazakh National Medical University, Named after S.D. Asfendiyarov, Tole bi, 88, Almaty, Kazakhstan
2 Department of Management and Obstetrics and Gynecology, Kazakh National Medical University, Named after S.D. Asfendiyarov, Tole bi, 88, Almaty, Kazakhstan
|Date of Submission||14-Jul-2014|
|Date of Decision||08-Feb-2015|
|Date of Acceptance||13-Apr-2015|
|Date of Web Publication||14-Jun-2016|
Aizhan D Kyzayeva
Department of Health Policy, Tole bi, 88, Almaty, Kazakhstan Almaty Kazakhstan
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Background: Over the last 10 years, the evidential practice has been developing in Kazakhstan. The clinical protocols of diagnostics and treatment were implemented in the country since 2007. We analyzed the normal birth practice in Kazakhstan. Materials and Methods: Obstetricians and midwives were subject to the questionnaire survey in four large Maternity Hospitals of Almaty. Results: Totally, 72 midwives and 50 obstetricians took part in the questionnaire survey. 4% of physicians indicated the regular use of enema, 11.1% of midwives and 24% of physicians — the shaving of the pubis, and the regular use of amniotomy was noted by 12% of physicians and 41.7% of midwives. At the second stage, the application of the Kristeller's method was noted by 8% of physicians and 11.1% of midwives. Conclusion: The noncompliance of the normal birth surveillance in Kazakhstan with the WHO's recommendations appears in the usage of routine methods at the first stage and of the Kristeller's method at the second stage of normal birth.
Keywords: Intranatal care, Kazakhstan, normal birth, obstetrics, recommendations, World Health Organization
|How to cite this article:|
Kyzayeva AD, Kudamanova AB. Normal birth in Kazakhstan: Labor management practice in accordance with World Health Organization's recommendations. J Res Med Sci 2016;21:42
|How to cite this URL:|
Kyzayeva AD, Kudamanova AB. Normal birth in Kazakhstan: Labor management practice in accordance with World Health Organization's recommendations. J Res Med Sci [serial online] 2016 [cited 2020 Oct 30];21:42. Available from: https://www.jmsjournal.net/text.asp?2016/21/1/42/183991
| Introduction|| |
World Health Organization (WHO) elaborated scientifically grounded recommendations on normal birth management in 1996. The recommendations provided the basis for clinical protocols of diagnostics and treatment in Kazakhstan implemented in the country since 2007. Until then, labor management in Kazakhstan included a great number of routine procedures (cleansing enema, amniotomy, and others) and did not differ from such management as applied in the times of the USSR. Having found its independence, the Kazakhstan public health service settled down to a course of reforming and improvement. Over the last 10 years, the evidential practice has been developing in the country including midwifery. A questionnaire survey was carried out in all maternity departments of Almaty. Almaty was chosen as it is a Megapolis of Kazakhstan with the maximum number of obstetricians and midwives. Thus, according to the Statistics Digest, more than 763 obstetricians and 856 midwives are currently being employed in Almaty that is higher than these indices in the other cities of the country. The questionnaire survey was voluntary and anonymous, and only those respondents were involved in the survey, who had signed an informed consent.
Direct physiological labor management: Physicians and midwives of the reception ward and obstetric departments.
Physicians and midwives of the Maternal Child Unit and the Functional Diagnostics Department, those from the administration and others, who do not participate in the labor management.
When drawing up the questionnaire, we relied on the similar surveys of other authors (evaluation of the medical-social and economic efficiency and the introduction of protocols on diagnostics and treatment in Kazakhstan-thesis). The representativeness of the sample was confirmed subject to the extent of the general totality — in 2013, the total of obstetricians in Almaty in maternity departments was 113, of whom those, who were subject to the questionnaire survey −50 (44%), and the total of midwives −316, of whom those, who were subject the questionnaire survey-72 (22,7%).
However, as the experience of some foreign countries shows, it is practically not always that one can fully succeed in the introduction of the evidential practice and the relevant WHO's recommendations. For example, in a number of both developed and developing countries, there is a low level of adherence to WHO's recommendations even in case of normal birth.,,,,,,,,,,,,
The compliance with the protocols of diagnostics and treatment in Kazakhstan in the normal (physiological) birth management was analyzed by us.
The aim of the research is to identify the degree of the usage of WHO's recommendations on intranatal care in Kazakhstan.
| Materials and Methods|| |
To conduct research, we made a questionary particularly for obstetrician-gynecologists and midwives.
Qualitative descriptive research based on the questionnaire survey.
Sociological method based on the questionnaire survey, statistical analysis, analytical method.
To carry on the questionnaire survey, an approval by the local ethical commission of the S.D. Asfendiyarov Kaz NMU was received (minutes of the meeting No. 4 dated 7.04.2014).
Obstetricians and midwives were subject to the questionnaire survey conducted by us in 4 large Maternity Hospitals of Almaty. The survey was carried out by the mass observation where in all the personnel participated, who was involved in the normal birth management in the clinic (doctors, midwives, interns, trainee doctors, and hospital physicians). The evidentiary medicine principles have been introduced in the Kazakhstan obstetrics during the last more than 10 years, and this process is being carried on a planned and consistent basis supported by the Government of Kazakhstan  and international organizations (EuroWHO, ZdravPlus, and others).,
Some foreign and domestic specialists provided trainings of medical professionals (obstetricians and midwives) in modern scientifically proved principles of easy delivery management. However by law, the rules of managing easy delivery are enshrined in such protocols on diagnostics and treatment as accepted in 2007, update-2010, 2013.
The findings were given in the absolute numbers and percent. The nominal data was compared by the Pearson Chi-square criterion. The critical significance level P = 0.05 when testing statistical hypotheses in the survey. Statistical analysis was made in the SPSS Program, Version 20.0 for Windows.
| Results|| |
At the first stage, the following practice of medical personnel is applied in Kazakhstan as per the questionnaire survey as shown in [Figure 1] and [Figure 2].
|Figure 1: Distribution of answers given by physicians to the question about the labor surveillance at the first stage|
Click here to view
|Figure 2: Distribution of answers given by midwives to the question about the labor surveillance at the first stage.|
Click here to view
At the first stage of labor, nonpharmacological methods of pain relief (point massage, self-massage and others) are used often-48.0% (χ2 = 25.750 df = 2 P< 0.001) according to the obstetricians and 51.4% (χ2 = 43, 702 df = 2 P< 0.001) that corresponds to the said WHO's recommendations.
Second stage of labor [Figure 3] and [Figure 4]. Pharmacological pain relief in labor is applied seldom in the Maternity Hospitals concerned 48% (χ2 = 4.0 df = 1, P = 0,046) based on the results of the questionnaire survey of the obstetricians, 50% (χ2 = 4.0 df = 1, P< 0.001) of the midwives.
|Figure 3: Distribution of answers given by physicians to the question about the labor surveillance at the second stage, %|
Click here to view
|Figure 4: Distribution of answers given by midwives to the question about the labor surveillance at the second stage, %|
Click here to view
Up to now, the amniotomy is used in case of the cervical dilatation at 8 cm or more-often - about 12.0% of the obstetricians so surveyed (χ2 = 9.6 df = 2 P< 0.001), and 41.7% of the midwives (χ2 = 19.702 df = 2 P< 0.001).
The case follow-up for a maternity patient at the first stage of labor is carried out by measuring of temperature, pulse and blood pressure. According to the questionnaire survey, 54.0% (χ2 = 60. 25 df = 3 P< 0.001) of the obstetricians monitor the state of the woman — every 4 h and 41.7% of the midwives (χ2 = 69.118 df = 5 P< 0.00), fetal heart beats — every 30 min (the obstetricians-48.0% (χ2 = 48.4 df = 3 P < 0.001), and 58.3% of the midwives (χ2 = 100.0 df = 3 P < 0.001).
The vaginal examination is made by 72% of the surveyed obstetricians every 4 h that corresponds to the WHO's recommendations as per the partograph.
At the second stage of labor, the Kristeller's method is used according to 8% of the surveyed obstetricians (χ2 = 10.4 df = 2 P = 0.006), 11.1% — of the midwives (χ2 = 19.659 df = 2 P < 0.001).
At the third stage of labor, the WHO's recommendations are complied with as follows: Controlled cord traction noted by 50% of the surveyed midwives (χ2 = 57.8 df = 2 P< 0.001), and 60% of the obstetricians (χ2 = 24.5 df = 1 P< 0.00), preventive medication of Oxytocin-63.9% of the midwives (χ2 = 35.280 df = 1 P< 0.001).
| Discussion|| |
According to such protocols of diagnostics and treatment as accepted in Kazakhstan, (Order of the Kazakhstan Ministry of Health, 2010), at the time of the survey, at the first stage of labor, the following was provided for in the RK: Case follow-up (measuring of temperature, pulse and blood pressure, uterine contractions, monitoring the fetal heart rate, partograph, and vaginal examination — every 4 h), and point massage, at the second stage of labor, in addition to the case follow-up, obstetrical aide; and at the third stage-controlled cord traction and preventive prescription of oxytocin.
According to the results of the questionnaire survey, despite the fact that the routine procedures such as routine use of enema fall in the Category B WHO (1996) the WHO's classification, that is, they are practices which are clearly harmful or ineffective and should be eliminated, the same has been still used in the Almaty Maternity Hospitals.
At the second stage of labor, unfortunately, the Christeller's method is used that can be noted in the answers of both obstetrician-gynecologists and midwives.
It should be particularly noted that some part of respondents both among the physicians and the midwives noted the usage of CTG at the first and second stages to monitor the state of a fetus even in the normal (physiological) birth management.
| Conclusion|| |
Thus, in analyzing the questionnaire survey of the said obstetricians and midwives, who directly manage normal (physiological) births, it was found that the Almaty Maternity Hospitals complied with the WHO's recommendations but not in all cases of normal births. Up to now, there are inadvisable procedures and measures such as cleansing enema, sanitization, Kristeller's method that requires the more detailed study of the causes.
This study was the part of dissertation work (Kazakh National Medical University named after S.D. Asfendiyarov). Project 618.1. Protocol no 4 (7/04/2014).
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
The authors have no conflicts of interest.
| Authors' Contribution|| |
ADK and ABK contributed in the conception of the work, conducting the study, revising the draft, approval of the final version of the manuscript, and agreed for all aspects of the work. Aizhan D. Aizhan D. Kyzayeva contributed in the conception of the work, drafting and revising the draft, approval of the final version of the manuscript, and agreed for all aspects of the work.
| References|| |
Statistic Database “Health of RK Polulation and Activities of Public Health Organizations” Over 2013, Astana; 2014.
Walker D, DeMaria LM, Suarez L, Cragin L; Evaluating Alternative Models of Obstetric Care in Mexico Research Team. Skilled birth attendants in Mexico: How does care during normal birth by general physicians, obstetric nurses, and professional midwives compare with World Health Organization evidence-based practice guidelines? J Midwifery Womens Health 2012;57:18-27.
Ith P, Dawson A, Homer C. Quality of maternity care practices of skilled birth attendants in Cambodia. Int J Evid Based Healthc 2012;10:60-7.
Khalil K, Elnoury A, Cherine M, Sholkamy H, Hassanein N, Mohsen L, et al.
Hospital practice versus evidence-based obstetrics: Categorizing practices for normal birth in an Egyptian teaching hospital. Birth 2005;32:283-90.
Sandin Bojö AK, Hall-Lord ML, Axelsson O, Udén G, Wilde Larsson B. Midwifery care: Development of an instrument to measure quality based on the World Health Organization's classification of care in normal birth. J Clin Nurs 2004;13:75-83.
Khresheh R, Homer C, Barclay L. A comparison of labour and birth outcomes in Jordan with WHO guidelines: A descriptive study using a new birth record. Midwifery 2009;25:e11-8.
Shaban IA, Hatamleh R, Khresheh R, Homer C. Childbirth practices in Jordanian public hospitals: Consistency with evidence-based maternity care? Int J Evid Based Healthc 2011;9:25-31.
Reale B. Intrapartum care in the twenty- first century. Nurs Clin North Am 2002;37:771-9.
Bai J, Gyaneshwar R, Bauman A. Models of antenatal care and obstetric outcomes in Sydney South West. Aust N
Z J Obstet Gynaecol 2008;48:454-61.
d'Orsi E, Chor D, Giffin K, Angulo-Tuesta A, Barbosa GP, Gama Ade S, et al.
Quality of birth care in Maternity Hospitals of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Rev Saude Publica 2005;39:645-54.
Qian X, Smith H, Liang H, Liang J, Garner P. Evidence-informed obstetric practice during normal birth in China: Trends and influences in four hospitals. BMC Health Serv Res 2006;6:29.
Adegoke A, Utz B, Msuya SE, van den Broek N. Skilled birth attendants: Who is who? A descriptive study of definitions and roles from nine Sub Saharan African countries. PLoS One 2012;7:e40220.
Choices and Challenges in Changing Childbirth Research Network. Routines in facility-based maternity care: Evidence from the Arab World. BJOG 2005;112:1270-6.
Wick L, Mikki N, Giacaman R, Abdul-Rahim H. Childbirth in palestine. Int J Gynaecol Obstet 2005;89:174-8.
The National Programme of Health Care Reformand Development for 2005-2010, Presidential Decree in September, 2004.
Abuova G, Mussagaliyeva A, Vujnovic M, Barnekow V, Bacci A, Kuttumuratova A. Support for mother and children. Entre Nous. The European Magazine for Sexual and Reproductive Health. Improvement of Maternal and Child Health in Kazakhstan 2011;74:6-8.
World Health Organization. Care in Normal Birth: A Practical Guide (WHO/FRH/MSM/96.24). Maternal and Newborn Health and Safe Motherhood Unit. Geneva: WHO; 1996.
[Figure 1], [Figure 2], [Figure 3], [Figure 4]